Bagel French Toast With Sweet Plum Sauce

I had tried french toast bakes before with regular sandwich bread but I always felt that they came out too mushy. The joy of french toast is the caramelized crunch of pan seared toast edges. This time around, I was inspired by Averie Cooks' to try bagels instead. Bagels are thicker and heartier which makes much more sense for a breakfast that you want to last over night and reheat well.

Recipe Tags


Example: #Lunch #Sandwhich #BBQ

Cuisine Tags


Example: #Spanish #Mexican

Created on

Favorited: 0

Your Rating

Servings: 5

Prep Time: 00:05

Cook Time: 00:25

Main Ingredients

5 slices of cinnamon bagels

1 cup granulated sugar

1/2 cup brown sugar

1/2 cup almond milk

2 large eggs

1 tbsp cinnamon

1 tsp nutmeg

pinch of salt

plum sauce (see my plum handpie filling)

optional: powdered sugar for dusting

plum sauce:

2 cups of water

1 cup sugar

2 red plums

pinch of salt

1 tsp ginger

1/4 tsp cornstarch (or tsp flour mixed with cup of water)


1Create the plum reduction by dicing the plums and combing with the 2 cups of water, 1 cup of sugar, ginger, and pinch of salt in medium pot. Boil on high for approximately 10 minutes. Stirring occasionally.

2Reduce the the heat to low-medium and add the corn starch or flour mixed with 1/4 cup of water. DO NOT add it alone or it will be lumpy. Strain the plum sauce from the fruit to use for later.

3Tear the cinnamon bagels into 1/2 inch chunks.

4Whisk the eggs, milk, brown sugar, 3/4 of the granulated sugar, and spices together in a large bowl. Combine the mixture with the bagel bits and allow to soak for 5 minutes.

5Pour the saturated bagel bits in to a nonstick or sprayed pan.

6Dust the top of with the remaining sugar and pinch of salt.

7Bake in the oven on 350F for 20-25 minutes.

8Dust with powdered sugar (optional) and drizzle with the plum sauce prior to eating. The sauce makes this dish phenomenal.

Additional Notes

This reheats really well. Mister and I have taken this with us a couple times this week. Just don't forget the sauce.

Reviews: 0

Select A Menu

Create A New Menu

Please enter a menu name

This menu name already exists. Please choose a different name



This recipe was added to . You can view here or close this window


Recipe Embed

Do you have questions or need help embedding recipes? Contact us at

In your blog post, create a "Link" with the text;

Set the link's URL or "href" to the below URL.

The link must include "?embed=link" and any additional parameters

In the footer of your blog (or below your blog post content) add the recipe embed code. This code can be embedded globally on your entire website, for use with all Kulinarian embeds.

You may need to refresh your page or blog post to see the recipe populate.

Detailed Instructions For Site-builders & CMS's